Last week I asked to hear your thoughts on Idol columnist Erin’s discussion on this season’s potential to create a Superstar Idol. I promised the best comment would get highlighted back here for thousands of readers so here it is from reader James, this week’s winner:

James: You’re absolutely right about AI’s checkered history in producing recording stars. The screams and shrieks on the show don’t necessarily equal a marketable career after the show. Even David A. is a wildcard — he probably can’t produce an album for adults and may not want to be targeted for 8-15 year old girls, where he would do quite well as a teen idol.

See what other fans had to say here on the post and add your thoughts too.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to AmIdolUpdates for Free by Email or RSS

Related Posts on AmIdolupdates.com:
Apple iTunes